Explainer: Why do reporters need shield laws?

Print More

What is a shield law, exactly? When can a government official require a reporter to disclose sources or information? Who counts as a journalist under a shield law? What types of sources or information are protected? Is there a big difference between a subpoena and a search warrant?  by Jonathon Peters CJR

This is a short and useful overview of the legal basis of “privilege” and in particular how journalists’ work is covered (or not) by privilege. The situation is nuanced, as states have different precedents and there is not a single federal shield law. The use of digital communication and storing information “in the cloud” has also complicated considerations of what information must be surrendered to law enforcement by reporters, who is a reporter or journalist, and when must sources be identified.

Shield laws and journalist’s privilege: The basics every reporter should know

Compelled disclosure is in the air. A federal judge has ordered Glenn Beck to disclose the names of confidential sources he used in his reporting that a Saudi Arabian man was involved in the Boston Marathon bombing. The man sued Beck for defamation after he was cleared of any involvement.